Best Butter Dish Ideas And Our Top Favorite Picks From Amazon

Butter is one of those ingredients that the world is better because it exists. If you love butter as much as I do, I assume you understand the disappointment that comes when butter is not kept clean or at room temperature for a quick bite. If this is you, then let’s look into the world of butter dishes so we can improve our snacking experience.

What to Look For in a Butter Dish?

As you begin looking for a new butter dish, you should consider what you need or want from your butter dish. There are a few features and factors that every butter dish has and that every person shopping for one should think about. These are:

Color

Butter dishes can be stylish and can make your kitchen and your table settings look great. Because of this, you should definitely get a butter dish in the color that suits your style.

Maintenance

How easy is a butter dish to clean? Very, when you find one that is dishwasher safe. Give your hands a break and select an item that can be machine cleaned, unless, of course, you prefer washing them by hand only.

Material

Butter dishes are made out of many different types of material, some more durable than others, some more stylish than others. Depending on how your kitchen runs, you may want a durable plastic butter dish instead of the cute and stylish ceramic butter dish. But, whatever you choose, just make sure you get what you need.  

For a little extra on what these materials are, here is a short reference guide:

Ceramic

Pros:

  • Available in a wide variety of colors, sizes, and styles
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Breakable

Glass

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Available in many different sizes
  • It makes it easy to view the butter

Cons:

  • Breakable

Plastic

Pros:

  • Inexpensive
  • Durable
  • Available in many different colors

Cons:

  • Not microwavable

Stainless steel

Pros:

  • Not a very common item
  • Easy to clean
  • Reasonably priced

Cons:

  • Only one color option
  • Some might have sharp edges

Wood

Pros:

  • Stylish
  • A rare item

Cons:

  • Hand wash only

Price

This kitchen item will range in price from low to high, depending on the material and the style you select. Remember, you can always find a good butter dish at a reasonable price, so there is no reason to overspend on one.

Size

Be sure to get a butter dish that holds all the butter you need it to. If you have a large family that consumes a lot of butter, it is best that you get something that will hold a lot of butter. However, if you rarely use butter, then don’t buy something extravagant.

What Products are the Best?

Now that we know all about what features to look for in a butter dish, we can begin looking at some of the best products on the market. To make our selections, we will use the following as criteria:

  • Material
  • Price
  • Ratings and Reviews 
  • Style

The Best Budget Butter Dish – Chef Craft Select Plastic Butter Dish

This is a very basic butter dish for everyday use. It will hold only one stick of butter, but it is inexpensive enough that you won’t be upset if it gets a crack in it.

Pros:

  • Inexpensive
  • Dishwasher safe
  • See-through design allows you to view the butter

Cons:

  • Breaks easily
  • The lid does not rest on the dish very well

The Best Butter Dish for Durability – Rubbermaid Standard Butter Dish

This is a great butter dish that is extremely durable and can even be transported to picnics and gatherings outside of your kitchen.

Pros:

  • Dishwasher safe
  • The lid is designed to fit securely
  • It comes in a set of two butter dishes
  • Reasonably priced
  • As of the writing of this article, 83% of the customer reviews for this item are 5-star

Cons:

  • Some customers have commented that the dish is not big enough for their butter

The Best Butter Dish Overall – Dowan Butter Dish

This is an amazingly stylish and practical dish. The bottom portion is made from ceramic, while the lid is made from wood. It looks great, and it works great for both east coast and west coast butter sticks.  

Pros:

  • Designed with an air-tight acacia wood lid
  • Large bowl design to hold plenty of butter
  • Made from lead-free ceramic
  • Dishwasher safe bowl
  • Available in six different colors
  • Customers love this dish because it is beautiful and practical

Cons:

  • Some customers have had issues with the lid seal not being properly attached

The Best Ceramic Butter Dish – KooK Ceramic Butter Dish with Lid & Handle

This may be a simple butter dish, but it does everything you need it to. Its basic design and style are going to make it fit into any kitchen or dining room.

Pros:

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Freezer safe
  • Microwave safe
  • Designed to be durable
  • Handle makes it easy to remove and replace the lid
  • As of the writing of this article, 87% of the customer reviews for this item are 5-star

Cons:

  • Not airtight
  • Some customers have had issues with the bottom of the dish scratching their countertop
  • Easy to chip

The Best Extravagant Butter Dish – LeCreuset Stoneware Butter Dish

If you need something fancy for your tableware, then look no further than LeCreuset. This brand name in kitchenware is known for its excellent designs, great colors, and quality products.

Pros:

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Safe for use in an oven and a microwave
  • Non-stick surface
  • It comes with a limited 5-year warranty
  • Designed to resist cracking
  • As of the writing of this article, 89% of the customer reviews for this item are 5-star

Cons:

  • Some customers have commented that the lid doesn’t fit the base very well

The Best Glass Butter Dish – Kangaroo Store Glass Butter Dish with Cover

This is as basic as a butter dish can get, and yet, it is completely wonderful. Customers are raving for this butter dish because it has all the features they want without the fluff.

Pros:

  • As of the writing of this article, 78% of the customer reviews for this item are 5-star 
  • Reasonably priced
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons:

  • Some customers have found that the butter will stick to the inside of the lid since it is narrow, while other customers have chosen to flip the dish upside down and use the lid as a bowl and the plate as a lid.
  • The manufacturer does not provide a lot of details about the dish.

The Best Ornamental Butter Dish – HAOTOP Store Whale Ceramic Butter Dish

You don’t have to have to get a dull dish to serve butter properly. Have some fun with your table, and use this cute whale-shaped butter dish to store and serve this condiment.

Pros:

  • Available in two different colors
  • Reasonably priced
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Safe for use in a microwave
  • As of the writing of this article, 89% of the customer reviews for this item are 5-star 
  • Customers love how large and how cute this butter dish is

Cons:

  • None

The Best Plastic Butter Dish – Butterie Flip-Top Butter Dish

This butter dish is amazing, and customer ratings confirm that it is worth the money. Its design is meant to keep the butter looking great, easy to slice or scrape off, and messes at a minimum. The features that make this possible are flip-top lids that keep the butter from touching the lid and a no-mess edge.

Pros:

  • Invented by women
  • Available in eight different colors
  • Includes a matching spreader
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Shatterproof
  • Made from BPA-free plastic
  • Made from food-safe materials
  • At the time of writing this article, 77% of the customer reviews for this item are 5-star

Cons:

  • Some customers have found that butter gets in to all the cracks of this dish

The Best Round Butter Dish – Godinger Butter Dish with Cover

For those who like something a little different for storing their butter, try this round butter dish. It is elegant enough to use at dinner parties, weddings, or other social events but still priced so reasonably as to make it an everyday item.

Pros:

  • Beautiful design
  • See-through design so that the butter is easy to view
  • Made from lead-free crystal

Cons:

  • Some customers have commented that it is very small and doesn’t hold a lot of butter

The Best Stainless Steel Butter Dish – Norpro Stainless Steel Double Covered Butter Dish

This is a nice and neat butter dish that can be used for everyday meals or dressed up for a fancy dinner. It measures 7.5” long by 4” wide by 2.5” tall and should be able to hold two sticks of butter or a block of cream cheese.

Pros:

  • Reasonably priced
  • Durable and doesn’t break

Cons:

  • Some customers have commented that the edges of this dish are sharp
  • Fingerprints will show up on the lid

The Best Wooden Butter Dish – HTB Store Bamboo Butter Dish

If you are going green and want to keep your kitchen gear eco-friendly, then this is the butter dish for you. It is made from sustainable bamboo, and it looks great too. The design is awesome since it has a place to store the knife and extended feet to prevent the butter from getting spread to the table.

Pros:

  • Made from eco-friendly materials
  • Large enough to hold west coast butter sticks and European butter blocks
  • Includes a bamboo butter knife
  • Designed to prevent buttery messes
  • Customers love the style and the size of this butter dish

Cons:

  • Some customers have commented that it is too long and too narrow for their liking

FAQs

Question: Is it safe to keep butter at room temperature?

Answer: Yes, the butter will stay fresh even when left on a countertop for a few weeks because it has plenty of fat, salt, and water in it. Just like milk and cheese, it is very easy to spot spoiled butter. Its appearance will be dark compared to when it was first set out, it will smell odd, and it will taste sour.

Question: How long does butter last?

Answer: This will depend on how you store it. If you leave your butter at room temperature (preferably below 70° Fahrenheit), it will last approximately three weeks. If you store your butter in a refrigerator, it should last for approximately three months. If you store your butter in a freezer, it will last for up to a year.

Question: Is there a difference between a butter dish and a butter keeper?

Answer: Yes, these two items are a bit different. While they both hold the butter in them and can keep the better fresh for many days, they work in different ways.  
A butter dish simply holds butter inside it. It will have a lid to keep pests and dust out of the butter, and it will keep the butter fresh for a few days. A butter keeper, also known as a butter crock or a butter bell, holds butter and water in it. The water, when changed every two to three days, works to keep the butter fresh for up to 30 days, even when set on a countertop.
If you would like to try a butter keeper instead of a butter dish, try the Dowan Store’s French butter dish with a lid. This butter keeper is simple to use and great looking. It comes in three different colors and is safe to use in an oven and a microwave; plus, it can be placed in a dishwasher or a freezer. If you’re unsure if a butter keeper is for you, check out all the reviews for this one so that you make an informed decision. BTW, customers love this item.

In Conclusion

After looking at all the wonderful options for butter dishes and the many styles and materials they are made in, I have to say I prefer the simple design of HTB Store’s Bamboo Butter Dish. The bamboo is aesthetically pleasing, and I really thought the customer feedback on this product was insightful. When I get a new butter dish, this will certainly be on my list.

Utensils of all shapes and sizes and usages are our specialty at Whisk and Mix. We love looking for the next biggest and the best thing for the kitchen and sharing what we found with you. I hope you found what you were looking for today and that your butter supply is better for it.

Now, if you need to find a way to use all that butter you are storing so stylishly and so well, why not check out our helpful guide on bakeware? With a healthy supply of butter and all the best baking equipment at your fingertips, you are going to eat well this holiday season—bon appetite.

Research Citations

Scroll to Top